Regie:
David MrnkaKamera:
Martin ŠtrbaBesetzung:
Ayelet Zurer, Robert Gant, Daniel Rchichev, Karina Rchichev, Taťjana Medvecká, Vica Kerekes, Igor Orozovič, Jaromír Dulava, Marián Mitaš (mehr)Inhalte(1)
A biopic about the prominent Czech lawyer and politician Milada Horáková, one of the victims of the 1950s communist “monster” show trials. Facing the two heinous totalitarian regimes of the 20th century, she defended democratic values and fought for freedom and justice. (Finále Plzeň)
Videos (3)
Kritiken (4)
Was ich an Mrnkas Milada am meisten schätze, ist, dass sie außerhalb der traditionellen tschechischen Strukturen entstanden ist. Scheinbar ist es ein tschechischer Film wie jeder andere, mit Geislerová in einer kleineren Rolle, Chýlková in einer größeren, Medvecká, Kerekes, Javorský, Mihulová, Dobrý... aber die Horáks sind Ayelet Zurer und Robert Gant, was ein sehr guter Schachzug ist. Das Thema wird ohne die Aufsicht unserer klassischen rückwärtsgewandten Institutionen behandelt, die Hauptinvestoren waren Netflix, EFB und DFG. Hier gibt es nichts anzuzweifeln.
()
A sad look at the domestic perception of our own history in filmmaking. David Mrnka, a screenwriter and director in one, has transformed into the author of a ninth grade essay question. One in which most direct speech consists of sparse sentences or pseudo-dramatic slogans. When these types of mottos are delivered with the usual dull dubbing (a particularly sad paradox in Czech cinema), the quality of the acting is more or less nullified. The only one who manages to shine is the underestimated Vica Kerekes, while the judge Aňa Geislerová or Jiří Vyorálek's Gottwald as an avid vodka drinker are, without exaggeration, in the category of parody. Milada herself, portrayed by Ayelet Zurer, works as an actress, but what she is forced to say is so absurdly profound that even she fails to handle it. When she melodramatically utters "Communists are like Nazis..." at a moment intended to be pivotal, all that's missing is a mischievous wink to the camera. It was not clear to me until the end whether the film was supposed to be four hours long and a lot had to be cut, or if Mrnka printed three pages of text from Wikipedia and just ticked off each item. Otherwise, I cannot explain absurd moments like "the main heroine is sentenced to prison, only to cheerfully return home in the following scene". Those who knew something about Milada Horáková before the start of the film will be disappointed, and those who knew nothing will end up with a helluva mess.
()
I didn’t want to be this critical, but I can’t help it. It is quite popular these days to open up political topics and tell the biographical stories of important personalities of our republic, or of former Czechoslovakia. And Milada Horáková is a topic with capital T. A topic that deserves respect, humility and a story that doesn’t have to be ashamed of itself. I am exaggerating here in my review. The film indeed doesn’t have to be ashamed of itself. But apart from a good technical execution and a more than solid actress from Israel, the movie lacks a screenplay that would give it at least a bit of sense. Personally, when I think about it, I have a problem with the fact that a debutant director was tasked with making a movie on this rather serious topic. Is Czech cinematography really so screwed that similar topics need to be assigned to a debutant director? Personally, I don’t think that David Mrnka is so bad, but I do think that he bit off more than he could chew here. Good moments alternate with truly bad moments and within the entire plot, it took a lot of effort to learn something about Milada. In the end, I didn’t learn anything new and it took a lot of work to convince myself to finish the movie. The only thing that we can all agree on is the portrayal of the typical Czech Communist, who for me is probable the most despicable human being in the world. And it doesn’t matter at all whether we are talking about communists from the past, or about communists today.
()
I totally agree that the existence of a film about Milada Horáková is necessary and essential. I’ll give it a star for the fact that someone tried to make one. But I can't do much more than that because cinematically it was one big dud that didn't touch me despite the strong story the filmmakers were trying to tell. I hope and believe that this topic is not yet closed to the cinematic world.
()
Werbung